In the field of precision manufacturing, EDM (Electrical Discharge Machining) machines, as core equipment for mold processing and complex part forming, have developed into two major categories: high-precision mirror EDM machines and traditional EDM machines. Although both operate based on the principle of electrical discharge erosion, they differ significantly in processing effects, technical configurations, and application scenarios, directly affecting an enterprise's production efficiency and product quality. For enterprises pursuing high-precision processing, clarifying the differences between the two is crucial for equipment selection and enhancing competitiveness.
In terms of machining accuracy and surface quality, high-precision Mirror EDM machines demonstrate overwhelming advantages. After processing with traditional EDM machines, the workpiece surface often presents a rough matte finish, with a surface roughness ranging from Ra1.6 to 6.3μm. Obvious discharge craters exist, with depths reaching 10-50μm. Subsequent manual polishing (such as oilstone grinding and sandpaper finishing) is necessary to meet basic usage requirements, and dimensional deviations are prone to occur when polishing complex cavities. In contrast, high-precision mirror EDM machines, through ultra-high-frequency narrow-pulse power supplies and uniform discharge control technology, can achieve a mirror-level surface finish of Ra ≤ 0.1μm. Some high-end models can even reach an optical-level precision of Ra 0.02μm, with the machined workpiece surface being reflective and requiring little to no manual polishing. The core reason lies in the powder-mixed machining technology adopted by mirror EDM machines (adding conductive micro-powders such as silicon carbide and aluminum powder), which enables "large, shallow, and uniformly distributed" discharge craters, with depths controlled within 5μm. After multiple finishing processes, surface defects associated with traditional EDM machines are completely eliminated.
Differences in core technical configurations are the root cause of the performance gap between the two. In terms of power supply systems, traditional EDM machines mostly adopt a low-frequency wide-pulse design, with a pulse frequency ≤ 100kHz and pulse width ≥ 10μs. They rely on high-energy discharges to quickly erode materials. Although rough machining efficiency is relatively high, discharge stability is poor, with an automatic arc-clearing response time ≥ 1ms, making local burn marks likely due to arcing. High-precision mirror EDM machines, on the other hand, are equipped with ultra-high-frequency narrow-pulse power supplies, with a frequency ≥ 500kHz and pulse width ≤ 1μs. They have a built-in dedicated "mirror machining circuit" (such as the PIKA circuit), support adaptive discharge gap control, and have an automatic arc-clearing response time ≤ 0.1ms, which can accurately avoid local overheating and ensure processing stability.
The gap in servo and drive systems is equally obvious. Traditional EDM machines mostly use stepper motors paired with ordinary ball screws (lead accuracy grade C5), adopt semi-closed-loop control, have a repeat positioning accuracy ≤ 10μm, an axial movement resolution ≤ 1μm, and a large discharge gap fluctuation range (15-50μm). They only support 3-axis linkage and are difficult to adapt to complex curved surface processing. In contrast, high-precision mirror EDM machines use high-precision servo motors + ball screws of grade C3 or higher + grating closed-loop control, with a repeat positioning accuracy ≤ 2μm and an axial movement resolution ≤ 0.1μm, enabling nanoscale feeding. The discharge gap is stabilized at 5-15μm, and some models support 4-5 axis linkage, easily handling complex curved surface processing needs such as turbine blades and optical lens molds.
The configuration of working fluid and filtration systems also reflects the positioning differences between the two. Traditional EDM machines have low requirements for working fluid, allowing the use of ordinary EDM oil (dielectric loss ≤ 0.05, impurity content ≤ 20ppm) paired with single or two-stage filtration (paper filter + mesh filter). No constant temperature control is required, and only the removal of large particle debris is necessary. High-precision mirror EDM machines, however, must use high-purity dedicated working fluid (dielectric loss ≤ 0.02, impurity content ≤ 5ppm), paired with a three-stage filtration system (primary paper filter + intermediate diatomite filter + advanced membrane filter), and stabilize the working fluid temperature at 20-25℃ ± 0.5℃ through constant temperature equipment. This is because impurities or temperature fluctuations will directly disrupt uniform discharge, leading to increased surface roughness. For powder-mixed machining, an additional micro-powder uniform mixing device is required to ensure stable processing effects.
In terms of application scenarios, the division of labor between the two is extremely clear. Traditional EDM machines are more suitable for basic forming needs such as ordinary plastic mold cavities, rough machining of hardware parts, and roughing of mold inserts. They are compatible with medium and low-hardness materials such as unquenched steel and aluminum alloys, and are widely used in industries with low precision requirements such as home appliances and toys. High-precision mirror EDM machines, on the other hand, focus on high-end manufacturing fields, such as the processing of artificial joints and surgical instruments in the medical industry (requiring a surface roughness below Ra0.1μm to reduce friction with human tissues), the processing of cooling holes in titanium alloy turbine blades in the aerospace field (dimensional accuracy ± 0.003mm), and high-precision demand scenarios such as optical lens molds and automotive lamp molds. They are particularly proficient in processing high-hardness materials (such as SKD11 and H13 mold steel) after quenching, avoiding dimensional deviations caused by heat treatment deformation.
In summary, high-precision mirror EDM machines and traditional EDM machines are not simply "upgraded versions" of each other, but differentiated solutions for different precision requirements. Traditional EDM machines meet conventional production needs with low cost and basic processing capabilities, while high-precision mirror EDM machines, with their advantages of high precision and high surface finish, have become essential equipment in the high-end manufacturing field. When selecting equipment, enterprises need to comprehensively consider their product precision requirements, industry positioning, and cost budgets to maximize the value of the equipment.
Phone
Comment
（0）